Thumb arthritis or tenosynovitis? Differences, signs and treatment

In short: In thumb base arthritis (rhizarthrosis), the saddle joint at the root of the thumb is worn – it hurts mainly when gripping, twisting and pinching, typically from middle age onwards. In de Quervain’s tenosynovitis, the tendons on the thumb side of the wrist are irritated – the pain sits slightly higher, over the bony end of the radius, and worsens when the thumb is moved. A medical examination, often with ultrasound or an X-ray, identifies the cause.

The two conditions lie only a few centimetres apart and are therefore often confused. They can even occur together. Telling them apart matters, because treatment and outlook differ.

The comparison at a glance

FeatureThumb base arthritis (rhizarthrosis)Tenosynovitis (de Quervain’s)
What is affected?Joint cartilage in the thumb’s saddle joint between the first metacarpal and the trapeziumThe tendon compartment holding two thumb tendons on the thumb side of the wrist
CauseWear, genetic tendency, previous injuries; more common in women after the menopauseOveruse from repetitive thumb and wrist movements; also common after having a baby
Where is the pain?Deep at the base of the thumb, where it meets the ball of the handAbout 1–2 cm higher, over the end of the radius at the wrist, sometimes spreading into the forearm
Typical signsPain when opening jars, turning keys or writing; loss of strength; later deformity and a bump at the thumb basePain when moving the thumb out and bending the wrist towards the little finger; swelling, sometimes creaking
CourseSlowly progressive, with better and worse phasesOften weeks to months; frequently settles with rest
DiagnosisExamination (e.g. grind test: pressing and rotating the thumb), X-rayExamination (Finkelstein test), ultrasound if needed
Treatment in generalSplint, hand therapy, pain relief, steroid injection; surgery for severe symptomsRest, splint, pain relief, steroid injection; occasionally surgery (release of the tendon compartment)

How can I tell which one I have?

  • Point to the spot with one finger: pain right at the base of the thumb suggests arthritis; pain higher up at the wrist suggests the tendon sheath.
  • Which movement hurts? Forceful gripping and pinching (opening a bottle, turning a key) mainly loads the saddle joint. Tucking the thumb into a fist and tilting the hand towards the little finger mainly irritates the tendons.
  • How did it start? A gradual onset over months or years fits arthritis better; onset after unaccustomed strain – such as intensive manual work or carrying a baby – fits tenosynovitis better.
  • Age: thumb base arthritis usually appears after 50; de Quervain’s tenosynovitis often between 30 and 50.

These pointers do not replace an examination. Other causes such as an unnoticed scaphoid fracture, trigger thumb or carpal tunnel syndrome are also possible.

Frequently asked questions

Can you have thumb arthritis and de Quervain’s at the same time?

Yes. The two conditions lie close together and can occur together. Treatment then usually focuses first on whatever is causing most of the symptoms.

What is the Finkelstein test?

The thumb is tucked into the fist and the hand is gently tilted towards the little finger. Marked pain on the thumb side of the wrist suggests de Quervain’s tenosynovitis.

Does a thumb splint help with both?

A splint that rests the thumb and, if needed, the wrist is used for both conditions. Its shape and how long to wear it depend on the diagnosis and are set by a doctor or hand therapist.

Does thumb base arthritis need surgery?

No, many people manage well with a splint, hand therapy and pain relief. Surgery is considered when these measures have not helped enough over a longer period.

Read more

General information only; it does not replace medical advice. Last updated: November 2026.

Sources